Was it not faithful to the book? All the changes Emerald Fennell made to Wuthering Heights with Margot

Reported Facts

Observable data points shared across all narratives

•Emerald Fennell directed a new film adaptation of Emily Brontë’s novel Wuthering Heights.
•Margot Robbie stars in Emerald Fennell’s Wuthering Heights adaptation.
•The film opened at the top of the box office with approximately $34.8 million in ticket sales reported by Arab Times (Kuwait).
•Media coverage describes the production as powered by women, referring to female-led creative and acting roles.
•Russian outlet RBC reports increased interest in Brontë’s novels following the release of the new Wuthering Heights film adaptation.
•Regional Latin American outlets report that Jacob Elordi’s acting in Wuthering Heights involved a scene in which a chair was broken during filming.
•Latin American media describe Emerald Fennell’s Wuthering Heights as one of the most controversial films of the year.
•A promotional or tourism-related offer allows people to sleep for free in a room themed as Cathy’s room from Wuthering Heights.

Narrative Split

How different information blocks interpret these facts

AFRICA

Tradition-challenging reinterpretation

African coverage portrays Emerald Fennell’s Wuthering Heights as a deliberate challenge to literary and cinematic tradition, focusing on its bold reimagining rather than strict fidelity. This block credits Fennell with intentionally disrupting canonical expectations to make the story resonate with contemporary audiences and debates, predicting that such reinterpretations will continue to reshape how classics are adapted.

•IOL (South Africa) characterizes the adaptation as a bold reimagining that challenges established literary traditions.
•This block frames Fennell’s changes to plot, character, or tone as purposeful interventions rather than incidental deviations.
•It suggests that the adaptation aims to interrogate or update the power dynamics and gender roles embedded in Brontë’s original.
•It anticipates that the controversy around these changes will fuel further critical discussion of how faithfully classics should be adapted.

REGIONAL

Controversial, transformative adaptation

Latin American outlets emphasize the adaptation’s controversy and intensity, highlighting both radical changes from the book and the physical and emotional extremity of performances. This block suggests that Fennell and the cast intentionally push the material toward greater brutality and passion to differentiate it from prior versions, accepting backlash from purists as the cost of making a culturally dominant, conversation-driving film.

•Milenio and La Nacion describe the film as the most controversial of the year, linking this to Emerald Fennell’s changes to the original story.
•Regional coverage notes Jacob Elordi’s physically forceful acting, including a scene that ended with a broken chair, as emblematic of the adaptation’s heightened intensity.

Female-led box office success

Middle Eastern coverage frames Wuthering Heights primarily as a commercial and symbolic win for women-led filmmaking, emphasizing its strong box office performance. This block attributes the film’s success to star power and a female-driven creative team, suggesting that audiences are rewarding such projects and that studios will be incentivized to greenlight similar titles.

•Arab Times (Kuwait) presents the $34.8 million opening as evidence that a women-powered production can lead the box office.
•This block attributes the film’s commercial performance to the combination of Emerald Fennell’s direction and Margot Robbie’s bankable profile.

Create a free account to read all perspectives

Already have an account? Sign in